Fintone Finance Free call

Guides

HMRC security notices: when PAYE arrears become the directors' problem

If a company falls behind with PAYE and National Insurance, HMRC can demand a security deposit. The demand can go to the directors personally as well as to the company, and ignoring it is a criminal offence. The best protection is to see a cash shortfall coming and agree a payment plan with HMRC before it sends a notice.

What a security notice is

HMRC calls it a Notice of Requirement. It is a formal written notice telling a person to give security because HMRC thinks PAYE or National Insurance is at risk of not being paid. The notice states the amount, the deadline, how long HMRC will hold the money and the right of appeal.

  • Who can receive one. The employer, and other people connected with it. HMRC’s own guidance uses the example of a company and its directors. Where more than one person receives a notice, each is liable for the full amount.
  • The deadline. It cannot be earlier than 30 days after the notice is received.
  • How security is given. A cash deposit with HMRC, a performance bond from a financial institution, or a joint account with HMRC.

How HMRC sets the amount

HMRC’s guidance sets out the calculation for an employer that pays monthly:

  • one month’s PAYE and Class 1 National Insurance
  • plus three more months, the time HMRC estimates it takes to wind up a business
  • plus the arrears already owed
  • plus Class 1A National Insurance due for the year.

So a company with a £25,000 monthly PAYE bill and £40,000 of arrears could be asked for about £140,000. The security covers the arrears as well as future PAYE. HMRC carries on chasing the arrears and can set the security against them if they stay unpaid.

HMRC normally holds the security for 24 months. It reviews the position at 12 and 18 months and can return the money early if PAYE has been paid on time.

Your options when a notice arrives

  • Ask for time to pay. The request goes to HMRC in writing. If HMRC agrees a payment plan, it does not require the security and withdraws the notice. If it refuses, you have a further 31 days to give the security or appeal.
  • Appeal. You have 31 days from receiving the notice. HMRC does not require the security until the appeal is settled.
  • Give the security. If none of the above applies, the security has to be in place by the deadline.

Doing nothing is the one option to avoid. Each person named can be prosecuted and fined. The government also plans to let courts disqualify a person from acting as a director for up to five years after a conviction, for offences committed on or after 1 April 2027. That change is due in Finance Bill 2026-27.

How to stay out of this position

  • Forecast the PAYE payments. PAYE is usually due every month and VAT every quarter. A 13-week cash flow forecast shows the weeks when they land together.
  • Talk to HMRC before you miss a payment. A payment plan agreed early is far easier than one requested after a notice.
  • Keep tax money separate. Our guide to cash reserves explains why PAYE and VAT should sit in their own pot.
  • Tell the directors. A security notice can name them personally. They should know the PAYE position each month, which is one reason it belongs in the monthly management accounts.

HMRC has similar powers for VAT, so a company behind on both can face more than one demand.

How Fintone helps

We build and maintain the cash forecast, flag tax payments that are at risk and help you prepare a time to pay proposal that HMRC can accept, through our cash flow forecasting and fractional finance director services. Request a free call.

Sources: GOV.UK, HMRC Securities Guidance manual: the Notice of Requirement, the person’s options, time to pay, the formula and how long security is held; and the Budget 2026 overview of tax legislation. This guide is general information, not advice for your circumstances.

Last reviewed November 2026 · Written by Joe Gilbert ACMA CGMA

Talk to Fintone

If your business has outgrown bookkeeping-only support, the first step is a conversation about where it is heading and what information you need to get there.